Dick
Forum Replies Created
-
using lithium can be done – the only issue is that it isnt just a drop in. I know that sounds “expensive” but I find that discussion ironic in that we’re dealing with hundred thousand to Million dollar coaches. And to get it working is essentially doubling the lithium cost (which is already more than AGM). . .
But you can account for all of those temperature considerations, alternator considerations and charging considerations as it is. and there are multiple ways to skin this cat .. but the only thing I disagree is that its a complete drop in replacement. of immediate note –
inverters – victron and mastervolt and you are generally set. Magnums you can make work. Outback you can make work. Most any that are fully programmable” can be kind of made to work.
alternator cut off – tie it in with a starter/gen battery and then just cut off charging after you hit above 14.1 or so. If you leave it lower – its not great, but it isnt catostrophic if it happens.
Load disconnect – easily handled by a smart battery protect.
Termperature is the same – on temperature too low, activate a relay and cut off charging…
Its doable to have everything taken care of. it isnt that difficult, but it will involve you or someone putting it together and installing it. I have my inverter on LiPO4 setting for charging and maintenance. 14.2 charge, 14.2 absorb for 1 hour, and float at 13.55. . . i generally prefer it to be disconnected actually rather than float charge it at the low amps, but the low amps helps keep the refrigerator and other draws going. I have a BMV712 that determines state of charge and monitors all the draws coming from the battery so I have a reasonable idea of what the battery state is (lithium batteries are notoriously difficult to get SOC based on voltage). The BMV also controls a dcdc battery charger off the alternator. it doesnt cut on until the battery SOC is below 60% and then cuts off at 90%. It is hooked in line with the generator start battery. So the inverter handles its charging when its connected to shore or generator. The alternator is handled by the BMV and DCDC charger. I dont have solar (but am considering it). There is a load disconnect on the load side that will cut off at 12.2. It cuts everything off except the battery monitor and GX controller.
-
Hi Anthem,
Thanks for your comments. Yes, there are lots of options if one wants to roll their own Li battery pack and control/balance management system. And, there are lots of options coming out of the marine industry that are interesting to consider as well. There very sophisticated companies like Victron who have done the proper battery/control system engineering although most of those remain in the very expensive category that many of our readers would consider over kill for our needs.
My comments are addressing the thread title “Is there a simple Li option?” and that focuses attention on the options that are far closer to drop in replacements for AGMs and cost effective to do so. Right now, my feeling is LiFePO4 is the closest chemistry to meeting that requirement.
Maybe some day we will be drawn to the chemistry Tesla just patented in December based on work they had been funding at a Canadian university. That chemistry promises a battery that could have the discharge/recharge lifetime to last for more than a million miles powering heavy over the road trucks. But, that is a long way off for us and our needs now…..
Jerry
-
Wow – OK – I feel stupid. Didn’t see the wiring diagram section and clearly need to spend more time on that site. A whole new world of info at my fingertips :-). Thanks for the info and patience.
-
There is one on the A/B board itself, left side of the rack…
-
Okay, thanks for the explanation. The flush out hook up on my coach only serves one purpose. That’s to flush out the black water holding tank. The problem with this arrangement is that the spray nozzle in the tank gets clogged and it quits passing water. It can be cleaned, but it’s a PITA.
A possible solution maybe.
What about making up a short hose about six inches or so with both male and female connections and screw it into the existing receptacle without the rubber washer but sealing it with RTV. That would seal the joint and give you an easier connection to use to use than the original flush connection was.
Just my “2 cents worth”.
-
If you have compression fittings they are likely not in need of replacement. But push in fittings are a whole different animal and since they don’t age well they should be replaced.
-
This has happened to me many times and sometimes the results were bloody, too. But after banging my head far too many times, I learned to duck automatically when I entered the bus when the TV is down.
🙂
-
Beaver Coach coverted 33
Country Coach for the sixty thousand numbered coaches. 60001-60491 there were a few others
-
Dick
My 95 Marathon has the 2 stage Jake, it was reprogrammed sometime in the 90,s to remain in 6th gear when Jake is applied.
I like the way it functions, i like the fact that it stays in 6th gear when i lift off the throttle, i keep it on in high at all times.
It holds my coach back very well when going through the mountains of western Canada, I dont think that there is a limit as to the extent of its use other than its own effectiveness, by that i mean as RPM decreases so does the effectiveness of the Jake requiring a downshift to raise RPM.
If i am in 3rd gear with 2nd stage Jake the only time i would apply service brakes is to maintain my max RPM of 2100.
I like the sound and the fact that it is serviceable by myself in the event of a problem.
In terms of Jake vs Retarder i think that a Retarder will prove to be more effective.
Gordon
-
There are certain things that make trading buses seem like a really good idea.
That is one of them.
-
But Roy, Have you colored outside the lines?
-
Was there Pacific which preceded Vision? Too long ago to be sure.
The reason it came to mind is it was the first converter I saw that painted the rubber fenders on the XL. I think.
-
Dick, any problem with space in Truck Stops to RON.
what is the general mood of the truckers? Did you get any adverse comments or gestures?
-
I found a cross reference website LINK that crosses over Prevost# 660987 to: Baldwin# P528 or Carquest# 85637.
Get NAPA to cross them over.