-
Side panel delamination on XLII models
Archived replied 11 years, 7 months ago 50 Members · 170 Replies
-
I think it is correct Tom, Simson/Bostik, 70-03 it is specificaly made for bonding panels during bus and truck construction. ( so descriptions says )
-
A bit off the subject, but has there been a study by Prevost or others,comparing 40′ to 45; buses? Are 40′ less likely to have the delam problem?
-
My opinion (I’m never short on opinions) on this delamination
of the stainless skin on XLII coaches: I believe the excessive heat created
during the polishing process weakened the bond.Many years ago – maybe 14 or 15, I asked Bill Jensen why
Prevost didn’t just install polished stainless during construction. He thought that might infringe on the converter’s
options during build-out. I thought that
comment was silly since virtually every coach gets the skin polished, and dropped
the subject.Anyone tend to agree that the heat caused polishing the
stainless could affect the cement bond? -
Let’s just say when that was floated as the reason and in essence placed the blame on the problem on the converters that went over like a fart in church.
It is known that is not the reason why the problem happened.
Many subsequent theories have been advanced ranging from process control to poor choice of product, but regardless of why it now appears the issue is gone and Prevost stood tall in dealing with the problem.
All of us that have had XL coaches which preceded the non-rivet coaches are well aware of how the skins will heat up in the sun, expand and then make some strange noises doing so. Then as the sun goes down and the skins cool there are addiitional sounds. Converters don’t have to heat up the skin polishing it because the sun does a beter and more widespread job of heating up the panels.
If in fact Prevost really believed the issues were the result of polishing it would be very simple to make the skins from factory polished stanless steel sheets and far less expensive in the long run hand polishing an entire coach.
-
I don’t think bringing it up again is a bad thing. There might still be owners who may be unaware there was an issue on XLII coaches and the discussion may prompt them to follow up on repairs.
-
I’m actually one of those prospective owners looking to purchase in Dec. ’15. Is it better to go to the XL model, prior to 2001, to avoid the delam issue? Is this the only major issue to look for and, if it’s been “fixed” will it hold?
Thanks for any thoughts on this,
Tim
-
Tim,
If you haven’t read it yet go to the Private forum. There are 18 pages of great information about the delam problem. I have a 2002 coach which had the issue. After the repair I am convinced it is permanent. I prefer the XLII but if I was making a new purchase I would get a very complete inspection from Prevost.
-
Mine has had it done and all is good i think for a long time if not forever . I do not think Prevost is participating in the issue anymore unless your are maybe a converter since Volvo took over ownership of the company , you will have to pay for the repair yourself , that is what I was told buy prevost, when I asked about it for a friend that wanted to buy a coach without it done and may have had a delam problem .
There will be no problems with the coaches that are riveted 2000 and older models
-
A “rivet” coach will not have the problem ever. That means an XL that was built with a skin attached with rivets, or an XLII that has had the repair using rivets.
However, that does not mean an XLII that has not been repaired, or has not been repaired using the rivet process has a delam issue. Each XLII should be inspected by Prevost and if there are any problems they can tell you what is involved in making repairs and if they will participate in sharing the cost.
-
Peter/Jon/ etal:
There exists the possibility of leaks on all coaches. The delam issue aside. Every roof penetration point will be subject to leakage at some time during the coaches useful life. For example, on my “Classic” coach we experienced a large scale leak during a severe thunder storm while in SC some years ago. I put roof sealer on every spliced panel and roof penetration. In 2013 while outside Philadelphia we experienced the recurrence of the leak. Turns out the seal between the roof escape hatch and the roof panel had failed. A temporary patch was made at the campground. The permanent repair was made by Jeff while having upgrade work done. I had all roof penetrations remade by Jeff as part of the work. I should now be able to sleep while hearing the raindrops dancing on the steel roof instead of inside the coach!
BTW, the leak showed up over the valance of the curbside window box. The actual leak was not the seam joining the roof panel to the side panel. It came in and followed the roof framing over to the window box.
-
I agree, but when we talk about leaks they fall under preventive maintenance in my opinion. I used to periodically look at the roof penetration seals and if it appeared they might be needing some work I would apply another coating of the flowable clear sealer that Camping World used to sell.
But I know there are guys chasing leaks on newer coaches that are associated with how the windows or skins are sealed to the coach and those are anything but predictable or even fixed by the owner.
-
I have had a XL and had leaks on the roof to vents to the window seals , I had the air horn leaking on my XLll dripping down and sometimes would follow air line down into steering bay or down front of windshield or drip right down on top of drivers chair that’s when I found it took pot light out and could see up in there and see it leaking !!! Sealed it all up and all well now!!! Also you should check panels on the XLll in between the windows those can also come loose the ones above the rivet process , I have seen those panels come loose too right where the window and panel meet , prevost will shoot locktite in there and re glue the panel , or take the hole panel off and clean it up and redo the hole skin , that’s a big job and can cost up to 20,000 per side
-
Just left our 2006 Liberty at Jacksonville Prevost to have the rivet-repair.
Prevost will pay for the rivet job, and we will have to pay for the paint job. Haven’t been told the
price of the paint job yet. Tried to get this rivet job okayed 21/2 yrs. ago at Nashville, but were
turned down by Prevost. While at Jacksonville, a few months ago, they did the pressure test and found many loose panels. Cindy was able to get the rivet repair okayed!
Hard to leave your coach in somebody else’s care for two months, but felt good about the technician,
Eric, who is doing the work. I told Cindy that I had read on this forum what a good job they have done on other coaches. She was proud to hear it! -
Bill Make sure if Cindy gives you a price on the paint you get it on paper, she told me 8-9 on my paint
when I got the bill it was over $11,0000, she told me she did not remeber telling me that. Darrell
Log in to reply.